Should I See Her This Weekend?

Lots of good advice yesterday. Really.
One more letter for the week and then we’ll do some results letters tomorrow and Friday. And don’t forget to chat today at 1 p.m.
From yesterday’s “blue in boston” to “Lost in Boston” …

Q.

Hi there,
There’s a woman in my life – “Cindy” — who is very special to me. We dated for over a year. Even thought it was a long distance relationship, Cindy and I had very strong bond, and intense feelings towards each other. We made it a point to see each other once a month. I live here in Boston and she lives in Detroit. We met on vacation almost 2 years ago and developed a very real, very strong connection to each other.
Last year I started a new job and she was in a very demanding program at school so our opportunities to see each other became few and far between. It had gotten to the point where it had been almost two months since we had gotten together. We both became very frustrated.
During our time together we literally NEVER fought, but one day we got in a disagreement and decided that we can no longer be an a “relationship”… but we continued to talk. Shortly after this “fight,” I had a long weekend approaching during which we had planned to see each other and I booked a plane ticket. About a week before I was supposed to leave she said that “that might not be a good idea” because she had been seeing someone else, but had not been physically involved with him. Well! To tell you the truth, I wasn’t completely surprised. After all, it had been more than two months at this point since we had seen each other — but it was too late for my plane ticket to be refunded.
I was perplexed by the fact that she used the words “together” in referring to him when they hadn’t been physically involved. She said she still wanted to see me but didn’t want to ruin anything that might-be with, let’s call him Dick. I was offended. So I called some of her friends who had been her roommates but moved out for the summer, and filled them in on what had been going on. They thought it was unfair and said that I should go anyways, and that if she really didn’t want to see me, that they would want to see me, and I could crash with them for the weekend. So I went. She never showed at the airport and I was heartbroken. Nevertheless, I had a fun weekend with her friends who helped me deal with what i was going through.
Fast forward six weeks later. After not even one phone call or a message; 2 a.m. on a Friday night i get a text that says, “I miss you,” which was shortly followed by a phone call from her. She told me how much and why she missed me and admitted she had made a mistake. I told her that sorry wasn’t good enough and she needed to prove it. Since then we’ve been trying to work something out for her to come here, but things keep coming up. Legitimate excuses, she has graduation i have to work, she has a wedding blah blah blah. But I have a four-day weekend starting on Friday afternoon, then not another long weekend until Thanksgiving.
At this point we haven’t spent anytime together since spring and were both dying to see each other, even though we know that because of the distance we can never have a REAL, NORMAL relationship. But I’m willing to swallow my pride and go see her be cause it very well could be the last time.
Should I make the trip out to properly end this relationship, or chalk up my experiences up as a loss and move on? I could DEF use some help on this issue before I would be leaving on Friday!

– Lost in Boston

Advertisement
A.

LIB, I’m not travel agent, but when a flight isn’t refundable, can’t you use the value of the ticket to go to another destination? I’m just saying.
You’re right — this relationship hasn’t been real. The fact that you rarely fought doesn’t impress me. You barely saw her.
We both know that Cindy has been immature and insensitive. It’s fine that she met someone else, but all of this jerking around with the trips and tickets doesn’t make me like her for you very much.
And I don’t like that you latched on to her friends in Detroit. I’m sure they’re great, but you saw them to get her to notice you. I’m sure you have your own friends in Boston who could have offered you the same support.
Some people need to end relationships in person to feel real closure. If you’re like that, fine, go to Detroit. But I think the real closure came at the airport, when you hoped to see a girlfriend waiting for you and didn’t. I fear that if you go out there to break up, she’ll just reel you back in.
You just told us that this will never be a “REAL, NORMAL relationship.” REAL and NORMAL are pretty great. I know it might be lonely and disappointing, but wouldn’t it be nice to spend the weekend wandering around your city looking for something real and normal?
Readers? Should LIB go to Detroit? Does LIB have to do the break-up in person? Does the 2 a.m. begging phone call mean anything? Share here.

– Meredith

Advertisement

To comment, please create a screen name in your profile

Love Letters

What’s your love and relationship problem?

Ask Meredith at Love Letters. Yes, it’s anonymous.

Advertisement
About Love Letters
Advertisement