On the Market

Inside the burned Dorchester house that sold for $776k

In three days, it went under agreement for the full asking price.

The house at 5 Weyanoke St. in Dorchester was heavily damaged in a 2024 fire. It's under contract for $776,000. Anthony Bruno of Gibson Sotheby’s International Realty

In November of 2024 a fire erupted at a two-family home in South Dorchester. No one was hurt, and the fire department put out the fire before it spread to neighboring houses, but it rendered the house at 5 Weyanoke St. uninhabitable.

It took the owner a long time to settle with the insurance company. In the meantime, the house stood empty, formally condemned by the City of Boston. Fire-scarred, missing pieces of the porch and roof, with boarded up windows and blocked-off doors, the house was the definition of the word “wreck.”

The back of the two-family house. Most of the damage happened in the front. – Anthony Bruno of Gibson Sotheby’s International Realty
The house at 5 Weyanoke St. in Dorchester was heavily damaged in a 2024 fire. It’s under contract for $776,000. – Anthony Bruno of Gibson Sotheby’s International Realty

Finally, the insurance issues were settled and the house was put on the market, with an asking price of $776,000. In three days, it went under agreement for the full asking price.

Advertisement:

“This is an indication of the overheated state of the Boston real estate market,” said Ellen Zumbado, a sales agent for Marsh Properties, Inc. “As prices in Back Bay, the South End, Beacon Hill, and the Seaport District have risen astronomically, areas that were once affordable have also seen prices rise. Any available property is desirable, even if it looks terrible.”

She believes that the house will probably be torn down and replaced with a new structure. In fact, the listing sheet information begins with the words, “Contractors, developers, and builders. Opportunity knocks!”

Anthony Bruno of Gibson Sotheby’s International Realty is the listing agent for the property. He believes that it is salvageable.

Advertisement:

“Most of the fire damage is in the front part of the property,” he said. “If someone wants to bring it back, I think it can be done.

A fire-damaged hallway. – Anthony Bruno of Gibson Sotheby’s International Realty
The fire damage extends into much of the interior. – Anthony Bruno of Gibson Sotheby’s International Realty

Because it is condemned by the city, interested parties had to sign an Assumption of the Risk/Hold Harmless Agreement before seeing it. “It is required by the city, but you can walk around inside without being in danger,” Bruno said.

During the time that the house has stood empty, it has not suffered vandalism. Built in 1910, it retains many original elements, including fireplace mantels, hardwood flooring, millwork, radiators, and newel posts. It has eight bedrooms in two units that occupy 3,953 square feet of living space. The house also has two off-street parking spaces and is located two blocks from the Ashmont T station.

Built in 1910, it retains many original elements, including fireplace mantels. – Anthony Bruno of Gibson Sotheby’s International Realty
The backside of the house has less damage. Built in 1910, it retains many original elements. – Anthony Bruno of Gibson Sotheby’s International Realty

This house may not have any curb appeal, but it’s “a wonderful opportunity for someone,” Bruno said.

“Lots of people have expressed interest. It has not sold yet; it is under agreement with a closing in May,” he added.

One of the kitchens in the two-unit building. – Anthony Bruno of Gibson Sotheby’s International Realty
One of the bathrooms in the two-unit building. – Anthony Bruno of Gibson Sotheby’s International Realty
One of eight bedrooms in the two-unit building. – Anthony Bruno of Gibson Sotheby’s International Realty

More Real Estate
Profile image for Regina Cole

Regina Cole writes about architecture and design for national and regional publications, with a specialty in historic architecture and the history of the decorative arts.

To comment, please create a screen name in your profile