Local News

Children of Catholic priests live with secrets and sorrow

Jim Graham, who believes he is the son of a Catholic priest, held his father's crucifix at his South Carolina home. Suzanne Kreiter/Globe Staff

By Michael Rezendes | Photos by Suzanne Kreiter, The Boston Globe

1 minute to read

He carried his doubts and disappointment across miles and decades, from childhood to adulthood, and finally at the age of 48 to the kitchen table of a modest house outside of Buffalo. There, he would ask an elderly aunt and uncle to help him answer the question that had troubled him all his life: Why had his father always seemed to dislike him so much?

With his parents already dead, Jim Graham pleaded with his Aunt Kathryn and Uncle Otto to tell him the truth about his family. Finally, Kathryn unfolded a newsletter published by a Catholic religious order and slid it across the table. She jabbed a finger at a picture of a sad, balding figure wearing a priest’s clerical collar.

Advertisement:

“Only the principals know for sure,’’ she said, “but this may be your father.’’

Jim Graham studied the picture. Those were his eyes, his nose, his mouth. Then he skimmed the obituary of the priest, the Rev. Thomas Sullivan, a cleric who had graduated from Boston College and trained for the priesthood in Tewksbury.

If a life can have a crystallizing moment, for Jim Graham that 1993 meeting was it, discovering that his father might have been a Catholic priest, rather than John Graham, the distant man who raised him with scarcely a kind or comforting word.

 

Finish the full Boston Globe Spotlight report on BostonGlobe.com. Don’t have a Globe subscription? Get a 2-week free trial.

Advertisement:

 

Watch reporter Michael Rezendes discuss his report on CBS This Morning: