Would It Be A Bad Idea To Apologize?

Contemplating a breakup? A crush? A divorce? Getting back on an app? What’s on your mind? Send a letter to [email protected] or fill out this form. Chat at 1 p.m.

Q.

I feel like my question is more of a “Post-Love” Letters thing. I’m in my early 50s and have been divorced for 16 years. In my 40s, I dated a woman for five and a half years who I thought was going to be my ride-or-die. When we spoke about our future together, she was very enthusiastic and made it sound as if she wanted the same thing. Then, just before COVID lockdown, she broke up with me via text message (yes…ugh). I was both confused and devastated since it came out of nowhere. It turns out she was cultivating the new guy in the background for two years while we were in a “monogamous relationship” and making plans to live together.

In the past 18 months I’ve done a lot of work on myself, trying to understand what happened, grieve the loss of the relationship, and heal. I’ve learned to minimize contact with her and, recently, I broke all social media ties. Once she realized that, she reached out to me to declare how thankful she was for all I had done for her and that she would like us to be friends. I told her in colorful, sometimes eloquent language just what I thought of her and how she treated me. Just to be sure that I burned that bridge to the ground, I reached out to her new boyfriend and told him what she was doing behind his back. It achieved the desired result. Unfortunately, now I regret what I did and I would like to apologize to her. I don’t want to do it because I want her back in my life. That would be very bad for me. I want to do it because it would give me a sense of peace since I was raised to take responsibility when I did something wrong. The question I have is whether this is a good idea?

– Asking for Trouble?

Advertisement
A.

Give yourself some time to see if your feelings change.

This recent contact was, well, recent. You lashed out, and now you feel bad. But maybe if you apologize, she’ll respond, and you’ll want to lash out again.

Basically, you have to be in a place where you really understand how to best process news about her life without you. It seems that small communication can change the status quo pretty quickly. For now, let your brain settle. If this happened a few weeks ago, maybe wait a month to see where you are and how you’re doing.

I’m all for accountability, but apologies are complicated sometimes. She’s still sitting with guilt, and now maybe some anger. You’re on very different paths. I do think that at some point, this will feel less raw. You’ll know it’s OK to communicate when you no longer have to wonder whether you’re asking for trouble – for yourself, at least.

If you ignore this advice and send the note, keep it super short. Say something like, “I apologize for the way I reacted to your note. It was the wrong thing to do. Clearly I’m not interested in friendship, and I hope we both can move on from this.” Like … two sentences. Maybe three. You’re not trying to start a conversation.

– Meredith

Readers? Apologize? Don’t? When?

Advertisement

To comment, please create a screen name in your profile

Love Letters

What’s your love and relationship problem?

Ask Meredith at Love Letters. Yes, it’s anonymous.

Advertisement
About Love Letters
Advertisement