What’s your love and relationship problem?
Ask Meredith at Love Letters. Yes, it’s anonymous.
What are your dating/relationship/marriage/single problems … email [email protected] or send your own letter here.
Not sure this is a question, a thought, or me just not being able to sleep at night. I met this guy three years ago. It was the first very strong connection I’d felt in such a long time. We met on a dating site. It read as a movie, finishing each other sentences, creating excitement out of any little thing. Then, just as fast as it arrived, it disappeared. Before even meeting, he seemed to suddenly lose interest. He explained he has bipolar disorder and had also met someone with the same diagnosis. He’d decided he wanted to pursue that relationship. I was at a loss, but I let it go.
I had just separated from my husband of nine years a few months prior. By the time the separation came, I had already been mourning the loss of our marriage for years. This new moment in my life was a gift, something unexpected. So I wasn’t mad at this guy when he explained what had happened. I wished him well and asked him to reach out if he ever wanted to in the future.
After a month, we connected again. This time we ended up meeting and then dating. I was head-over-heels for this guy. He had a place by the water and we would spend summer nights in his apartment, windows open, the music flowing. It lasted four weeks before he left a nine-second message on my phone saying, “Yeah, I just don’t know,” and disappeared again. I was devastated.
Yes, he appeared and disappeared again – and again and again. Like this for three years. I could describe every single detail, but this letter could go on forever, and I might feel a bit silly trying to explain why I didn’t give it up. We are no longer together. It has been a few months now. This time I did the unthinkable and actually blocked him, for his sake and for mine. I am dating, and I feel OK about it all.
The thing is, if I were to think of my last day on Earth and the world is ending, I think I still want to wake up with him. I want to go back to that apartment, by the water, with the open windows and the breeze. And that energetic feeling, and that voice that I could listen to for hours. I read the other day somewhere that fidelity is not about staying forever, it’s about continuing to come back. Even now, I can’t help but smile when I think that maybe there is still a chance that I will see him again and that we will be close again. Not sure what this means for us, but isn’t it wonderful to keep feeling love regardless? How do I manage these feelings?
– Smiling
If it was the last day on Earth – world ending, for sure – I would gather my family and friends, watch movies, and eat a ton of food that is terrible for me.
But as far as I know, the world is going to survive the day, which means I shouldn’t eat the terrible food.
This man was like that kind of food (maybe even the cotton candy I love so much), which is why I’m so glad you blocked him. Now it’s time to refine what romance can look like. Sometimes it’s calm and consistent. That can be fun too, I swear.
Showing up with great passion might seem like the most interesting kind of love, but I’d argue that if you have to keep returning after disappearances, it’s not romance at all. This person was only as good as his nine-second breakup message and all of his exits. As you think of him fondly, please remember everything he did, not just the warm breeze.
I do think there’s something to that comment about fidelity, but I think it refers to relationships that last more than four weeks at a time and don’t involve 5,000 breakups. It’s about falling in love with the same person over and over again. He wasn’t with you long enough to have to do that.
I’m glad you can smile about him. But please allow yourself to grin when you realize he’s gone. It was a chapter of your life – a vibrant one – but it caused you stress and pain. It was inconsistent and didn’t go the distance. Letting go of him required bravery, and that’s something to celebrate.
Smile for yourself because you’ve moved on. Don’t fantasize about another try; instead, focus your energy on the new experiences in front of you.
– Meredith
Readers? Is it OK to smile about this relationship? Is that smiling preventing something new from sticking?
Have advice for today’s letter writer? Be helpful. Be clever. Get your comment featured here.
Meredith Share Thoughts
Ask Meredith at Love Letters. Yes, it’s anonymous.
Sign up for the Love Letters newsletter for announcements, hand-picked letters, and other great updates from the desk of Meredith Goldstein
Stay up to date with everything Boston. Receive the latest news and breaking updates, straight from our newsroom to your inbox.
Be civil. Be kind.
Read our full community guidelines.To comment, please create a screen name in your profile
To comment, please verify your email address