Questioning my good marriage. (I always had doubts.)

Is there something on your mind about a relationship in your life? Or a relationship you wish you had in your life? Send your own question. Help others wondering the same thing. Use the form – or email [email protected].

Q.

I’ve been married for over a decade, and my husband and I have two small children. For years before we were married, l fought doubtful thoughts about whether I was in love with this person (Let’s call him “Joe”). I rationalized that everyone around me, including my closest family and friends, thought he was terrific, so that must mean I was lucky to be with him. 

I have had my share of serious and non-serious relationships in my life, so it wasn’t that I was inexperienced, but maybe lacked confidence to trust myself. I was drawn to Joe because he was kind and handsome and we had a lot in common. It was clear he was safe; as in, not going to hurt me or leave me. 

We have always had fun together, but our partnership has never been that deeper connection I experienced in the past with other partners, even ones who had terrible tempers. Long story short, we dated for a few years and timing was right and we wound up getting married. 

I was anxious the whole time planning the wedding, but told myself I was being too critical or judgmental and I needed to be more grateful for Joe. With our community supporting us, we had a gorgeous wedding and went on to have incredible kids. 

All this to say: lately I’ve just felt like the depth of our connection is hitting me in the face all the time. And as I’ve matured, I trust my instincts more than I did when I tried to brush them away years ago. My husband is a good guy, but I’m worried I don’t love him. How do I know if this is true? I think about other men frequently. I don’t think I would ever cheat, but I’m not satisfied. I love my kids and the idea of our family, but part of me just feels empty and the feeling just doesn’t go away. 

I don’t want to hurt my family. I also don’t want to miss out on real connection in my life if this isn’t it. Do I just suck it up? Please help.

– Feeling Empty

Advertisement
A.

“Depth of connection.” 

If we were in a room together, I’d ask you more about that. What does it mean to have a deep connection? Is conflict required? Is it about someone showing you a view of the world you’ve never seen before (through conversation, etc.)? 

There’s no right answer here. I’m just curious because it’s so important to feel like a partner really gets you, and that you have a shared sense of humor, vision, and take on the world.

Is all of that stuff missing?

If all you feel on a daily basis is, “great, what a nice guy,” … you might need to make changes.

My advice, shocking no one, is to talk to a counselor about your feelings. Discuss the missing pieces that are difficult to describe in this letter.

Something to consider as you dive into this: husbands aren’t supposed to be everything (and by husbands, I mean partners of all kinds). I’ve been interviewing researchers about the way romantic couples can become isolated. Sometimes they’re a lot lonelier than single people. If you have kids, there’s not a lot of time to connect with other adults.

That puts so much responsibility on one life partner to be: the funny one, the helpful one, the smart one, the best friend, the person who sees you for exactly who you are.

That pressure to be all things turns a spouse into a disappointment pretty quickly.

I don’t know if that’s the issue with Joe. It does sound like you made a bunch of decisions based on the confidence of other people. 

Please talk to a therapist about who you are now. Also talk to Joe, when you can explain your thoughts with more clarity. He may have surprising ideas about your marriage.

Sometimes when one person is going through the motions, the other follows their lead. Asking big questions lets your spouse know they’re allowed to do that, too.

– Meredith

Readers? Thoughts on these doubts? Advice about next steps?

Is there something on your mind about a relationship in your life? Or a relationship you wish you had in your life? Send your own question. Help others wondering the same thing. Use the form – or email [email protected].

Advertisement

To comment, please create a screen name in your profile

Love Letters

What’s your love and relationship problem?

Ask Meredith at Love Letters. Yes, it’s anonymous.

Advertisement
About Love Letters
Advertisement