Forgiving myself for the affair

Send your own anonymous relationship, dating, and friendship questions to [email protected] or fill out this form.

This is a good time to do that.

Q.

My wife, my child and I were living abroad some years ago when I fell in love with someone else. After we left the area, it became a full-fledged affair; my family and I had to be separated for family reasons. I was deeply in love. I mean it.

The truth was that my wife and I were a bit of a crisis. I would never have left her, particularly because of our child. But I deceived myself into believing, and I’m serious, that I could have two marriages. My job did allow for a lot of travel. I made plans to move part-time to this other country with my girlfriend. 

Instead, my girlfriend began getting increasingly distant. She had hopes. They were real. But she knew what I didn’t want to accept: it was love, but it wasn’t going to happen. She was the one who broke it off. I argued for a few days and then let it go.

I still love her. I think you can love two people in life at the same time, but the hard truth is, someone is going to be hurt. If I could do it over again, I’d have told my wife we needed counseling. She would have gone. We’ve since had another child, and it’s a good marriage.

But I’m aware that I dodged a real bullet. Someone else took the responsibility for ending what was wrong to begin with, and she never, ever talked about approaching my wife, the way it sometimes happens. I’ve never picked up the phone or written. I’ve been tempted. 

I’m reasonably—I’m being as honest as I can here—happy that the other person (the former girlfriend) is getting married after a two-year relationship with someone who lives close to her, someone she met about a year after she broke up with me.

In this case, I did love the other person and I always will. I just couldn’t believe how quickly my brain went back into criminal mode, and how quickly I was able to suspend my own morality.

The few friends I have told about it say I need to forgive myself, and I have, but I don’t think forgiveness works without responsibility. There’s nothing wrong with saying that one was wrong, and I was. I remind myself of that every day. It felt good to be loved by someone else while my life and marriage were in a bit of a crisis. But it never should have been more than that.

– Forgiveness

Advertisement
A.

There’s not much of a question here, but I think a few are implied.

Are you allowed to forgive yourself? Yes.

Is there any reason to call your ex-girlfriend and apologize for the fact that she was the one who had to initiate the breakup? No. Please leave her alone and stop monitoring her from afar.

Can you continue to keep this from your wife? Sure, if that’s what feels right. I suppose you’ll always run the risk of her finding out from someone else. A friend of a friend? A security camera? Only you know whether you’ll catch yourself in a lie – or freak out and have to tell her because you can’t keep it in.

It’s difficult, I imagine, to learn a huge lesson about yourself – to have a big experience that deals with morality and bonding – and have to keep it a secret. You had a revelation about your own needs and priorities, and you can’t tell most people about it. 

If you need to talk more (this letter suggests you might), seek counseling on your own.

I agree that forgiveness works better with responsibility – or accountability. You do seem to be putting the lessons you learned into your marriage. 

I would just ask a question of you: can you let it go now? Can you live your life and keep the experience in your past? If there’s more to say, figure that out. But if you’re ready for the next chapter, dive in.

– Meredith

Readers? I’d love to know if you believe that forgiveness can happen without disclosure of betrayals, etc. How does one let go of this without big conversations?

Send your own anonymous relationship, dating, and friendship questions to [email protected] or fill out this form.

Advertisement

To comment, please create a screen name in your profile

Love Letters

What’s your love and relationship problem?

Ask Meredith at Love Letters. Yes, it’s anonymous.

Advertisement
About Love Letters
Advertisement