I Think He Should Say He’s My Boyfriend

Q.

Hi Meredith,

I’m a college student in Boston, currently in Los Angeles for an internship this summer. I’ve been here for more than a month and was fortunate enough to meet a great guy. Last night, we discussed our relationship, and he told me he is not interested in seeing anyone else. However, he’s not comfortable with the terms “boyfriend/girlfriend” for two reasons: 1. I am leaving at the end of the summer, and he doesn’t like the idea of just being a “two-month boyfriend,” and 2. he is a recovering alcoholic and is very much focused on his health and wellbeing right now.

In the past, I’ve always lived by the rules that I am either casually dating someone or I am their girlfriend. I am glad he is being honest with me about what he needs, but I can’t help but feel that a guy who is truly interested would have no problem being my boyfriend, despite life’s inconveniences. I tend to live by the book “The Rules,” if you can’t tell.

Why do I want the label? Well, I care for him a great deal, and I’d like to be able to have a concise way to state that. We have a solid relationship, and “so-and-so, a guy I’m dating exclusively” sounds unnecessarily complex to me. Why not just call it what it is?

Also, maybe part of it is that I don’t think our relationship needs to end when I leave. I fully intend to be back in Los Angeles next May after graduation, and I’ve done long-distance for longer periods of time before. We haven’t discussed this as a possibility.

I should be ecstatic about our conversation about exclusivity, but instead, I am hung up on the label. What do you think?

– Label-less in Los Angeles

Advertisement
A.

Please do not live by the book “The Rules.” Please. The happiest, most genuine couples I know broke every one of those stupid rules. The person who screams “I’m your boyfriend!” from the top of the Hollywood sign, two months into a summer relationship, is not being real. You can’t expect him to have all the answers right now.

Your issue isn’t the label; I will not accept that this letter is about how to explain this man to other people. (It’s pretty easy to introduce him by name.)

The real problem is at the end of your letter – the fact that you want to continue this relationship after you leave, and he might not. He’s already told you he needs to concentrate on himself for a very good reason. He might not be able to give you any guarantees.

Start preparing yourself to return to Boston without a big answer, and consider that leaving things open-ended – without a label – might be the best option for you, too. You’ve only known this guy for the summer. It’s way too early to be sure you want more.

– Meredith

Readers? The Rules? Label?

Advertisement

To comment, please create a screen name in your profile

Love Letters

What’s your love and relationship problem?

Ask Meredith at Love Letters. Yes, it’s anonymous.

Advertisement
About Love Letters
Advertisement