Stuck on a first

Send your own anonymous relationship, dating, and friendship questions to [email protected] or fill out this form, and you could win a getaway.

Q.

I can’t seem to get the guy who took my virginity out of my mind and it’s driving me crazy.

We flirted on and off on a dating app and on Instagram, and then he offered to come over. I thought he was incredibly good looking, and he was physically my type. After the deed was done, he ghosted. We still follow each other on Instagram, but I’m in anguish knowing he’ll never contact me again.

For context, I was in a stressful and dark period in my life at that point. I felt super alone and mentally tired, and he was kind of a light in my life. I got super attached to him, and although it’s been about a year, I still think about him and what could have been.

I know I’m not really his type (style-wise). I think he thinks I’m too shy. Maybe he thinks we weren’t sexually compatible. He’s soft-spoken but extroverted and loves the gym, going to music festivals, etc. I just feel so upset because I got super attached to him, and I can’t bear the thought of seeing him with anyone else. I’ve driven my friends crazy talking about him constantly, but what can I do when he’s always on my mind?

I tried the usual strategies of concentrating on his negative points, blocking him on other social media, attempting to accept reality, but it’s so hard. My dumb brain refuses to see him in a negative light. My friends say I have too much respect for him and he has little for me. That I deserve better than someone with no job or future career prospects, but I would genuinely overlook that (I know, I know) because I think we’d make cute babies together.

Can you help a girl out? Or offer words of comfort? Sometimes I cry when I think about him.

– Stuck

Advertisement
A.

You know why he seems so important. You were in a stressful, dark period in your life. He brought lightness to it.

You experienced something new with him. He helped make that event pleasing (I assume).

Of course you’re going to think about him a lot – and romanticize all he can offer.

But the thing is, most of what you’re attached to is your own story about who he might be. You don’t know what he’s like at a music festival (he might be in a bad mood the whole time). You have no idea whether he’s soft-spoken but extroverted (have you ever seen him at a party?). You’re inventing a full character portrait for a man who was in your life for a short time. 

What you know: he was a great one-night experience … and he has not called you back.

My advice is to start romanticizing people who do call you back. Sounds simple, right? Well, it is. I wish I’d learned that when I was younger. Get psyched about someone who shows up and surprises you – someone who might be coming to you for a new experience. 

Get out there again, because the longer you sit around thinking of one man, the more important he gets – for no good reason.

You don’t have to seek a serious partner; these can be more casual, exploratory relationships. I have a feeling that the more you surrounded yourself with new faces, the less time you’ll have to stare at a wall and fantasize about a guy you’ve blocked on Instagram.

That’s another thing: stay busy. It’s harder to fall into a pit of longing if you’re on the go, doing activities that demand your full attention. 

If your brain gets stuck in a story about how he’s your soul mate, say this out loud: “That is not true. I’m making this up.” Accept that it’s fiction and move on with your day.

– Meredith

Readers? How do you get over a short connection that seems larger than life?

Send your own anonymous relationship, dating, and friendship questions to [email protected] or fill out this form, and you could win a getaway.

Advertisement

To comment, please create a screen name in your profile

Love Letters

What’s your love and relationship problem?

Ask Meredith at Love Letters. Yes, it’s anonymous.

Advertisement
About Love Letters
Advertisement