Should I Just Go With The Flow … With Sex?

It’s your turn to write a letter. What are your dating/relationship/marriage/single issues? Let us try to make sense of them. Submit a letter here. You can also email [email protected].

Q.

I am 23 and have been in a relationship with my girlfriend for the past eight years. Basically, we are high school sweethearts and have been in an on-and-off relationship, mostly long-distance, and we talk over the phone and meet up a few times a year. I love her and she loves me.

A while back, during one of our late-night conversations, she told me she was against sex before marriage – that is she is a devout catholic and traditional. She brings up the marriage issue casually; she’s never asked me whether I want to marry her. I only talked about when (what age) I would consider marriage. Basically, I have not made serious promises about the future because commitments mean something to me and I always follow through. I just want to be in the relationship for now and see where this takes us.

Recently she has been giving me hints that she is ready for sex and wants to get more physical. Do I just go with the flow or avoid the act because she was so serious about her boundaries in the first place? I wouldn’t want her to resent me in the future.

– Promises

Advertisement
A.

I don’t know what you mean by “go with the flow.” This is going to require a clear conversation. If she tells you she wants to have sex, you should ask her what’s changed.

It’s very possible she’s reset her expectations and wants to try something new, but you have no idea. Ask her how she feels. Do not guess.

If she tells you she’s open to having a more physical relationship before marriage – and that she knows you have not promised a future together – believe her. If she says she’s thought about this and is sure about it, don’t ask her to promise not to resent you in the future.

You can’t control her future feelings. If you break up, she could resent you for a bunch of reasons. That’s how breakups work a lot of the time. You might resent her too.

You said you want to be in the relationship and see where it takes you. What a great, honest way to tell her where you are. You can say you’d like to have sex (I assume that’s true), and explain what the act might mean to you. Maybe it would bring you closer. Perhaps you’d learn more about each other. This could help the relationship grow. But it wouldn’t be a placeholder for a promise you’re not ready to make.

Talk about it. This is not something you want to pursue from a place of confusion.

– Meredith

Readers? What are the right questions to ask? Should the LW stay away from this until the whole relationship is on a more serious track? Thoughts on the long-distance of it all?

Advertisement

To comment, please create a screen name in your profile

Love Letters

What’s your love and relationship problem?

Ask Meredith at Love Letters. Yes, it’s anonymous.

Advertisement
About Love Letters
Advertisement