I Want Her To Be My Wife … Someday

It’s your turn to write a letter. What are your dating/relationship/marriage/single issues? Let us try to make sense of them. Email [email protected] or send your letter here.

Q.

Hi Meredith,

I met this woman through the apps during the height of the pandemic. We met up, hit it off, and a beautiful but complicated relationship has been the result of it. She loves me and supports me unconditionally, and I love her more than anything. I feel like she truly understands me. But we also have a very toxic cycle of breaking up and getting back together that I take a VERY big part in being responsible for.

We break up, spend a month or two apart, and then come back and are good for two to four months, then break up again. I’m a little older (31 to 26) and I can admit and be self-aware that I have commitment issues. My job (bartending) and lifestyle play a huge part in this complication. I want to eventually marry this woman and grow old with her, but I don’t feel ready to give up my agency and freedom or my lifestyle yet.

My question is, do you have any advice (besides therapy, which I’m already trying) about how to make sense of a powerful but messy connection? We want to end up with each other but it just doesn’t work right this second logistically. I’ll never keep her from happiness. I’m not jealous or selfish, but I love her and want her to be my wife one day, even if I’m not ready now. I feel hopeless and would love any help trying to find a center.

– Lost & In Love

Advertisement
A.

“I’ll never keep her from happiness.”

Are you sure? Because it sounds like you’re basically saying, “I want her to stay with me – or wait for me – until I’m ready for a lifetime commitment.” That doesn’t sound wonderful for her.

Be honest about what you can deliver. It doesn’t have to be all or nothing. If you want to see her but keep things open, ask her about that kind of relationship. If you want to stay together but see her less, tell her that’s where you are right now. Then ask her if she can be happy with what you’re offering. My guess is the answer will be no, but you never know – she might be open to something more … open. This is about stating your intentions – honestly and transparently – and then giving her the option to accept or walk away.

For the record, I’m not sure you have commitment issues. It sounds like this is more about you not being ready for a serious relationship (which is OK!) but trying to force it. It’s also about your assumption that you know what’s best for your future self. You want this woman to be your wife even though you can’t spend more than a few months with her. How can you be sure you’ll be good for each other in a decade or more? What about focusing on now? You’re still figuring out what kind of life you want, right? It might help to detach yourself from the narrative that she has to be your endgame.

You say you want to find your center. I think that happens when you accept where you are and all the uncertainty that comes with it. You’ll have to stop pushing yourself – and her – to be in a relationship that requires more than you can offer.

Take some time to think about what you want in 2023, not years from now, and talk about it.

– Meredith

Readers? Is this about commitment issues? How do you keep someone around for the future if you’re not ready now?

Advertisement

To comment, please create a screen name in your profile

Love Letters

What’s your love and relationship problem?

Ask Meredith at Love Letters. Yes, it’s anonymous.

Advertisement
About Love Letters
Advertisement