Are We Getting Back Together?

1. We’ll chat on Thursday instead of tomorrow. 2. New stuff over on LL Facebook page.

Q.

Hi Meredith,

I dated someone for six years (three of four years in college and two after). He lives in Boston, I lived in Connecticut. I’m 25, he’s 26. We had a pretty good relationship, loved each other, and were best friends. We used to visit each other every weekend and have fun together.

Fast forward to last summer, the day of our six-year anniversary, which is when we broke up. Why? Well, I got a job in Boston and decided to move here. First I asked if he wanted to move in together. He didn’t love the idea, so I decided to stay with him for a couple of weeks while I found a place. He freaked out about the whole idea of living together and we broke up.

After six years, we didn’t talk for about two months, then texts started happening here and there. We started seeing each other once every couple of weeks. One of the times I did some snooping and found out he had slept with another girl, so of course I got mad. Because he did that, I decided to have my own experiences (let’s say within five months I slept with four guys). The thing is, he doesn’t know this. We have been going back and forth about this situation for a year now. It has taken this long because he works A LOT, so every time I wanted to have a conversation, he just said, “I’m too tired to fight” or “I don’t want to talk about it.”

Fast forward to today. We see each other every weekend, still talk about everything (family, friends, things at work), and of course we are still being intimate. I have noticed that sometimes he’s distant, but other times, like yesterday, he can’t stop hugging me and he won’t let go. I have tried to have multiple conversations with him but we are not very good talkers, so things are a bit complicated. I’m confused as to what he wants. Does he want to get back together or just be my friend with benefits?

– in love and confused

Advertisement
A.

First thing to know: Your experiences with these other men are none of his business. There was no promise of exclusivity when you slept with those guys. He’s allowed to ask whether you’re pursuing other sexual partners, but you don’t owe him more than confirmation.

Second, this whole thing can be resolved (for the most part) with one easy question: “Should I be dating other people?” His answer will tell you how much to invest and whether you have any reason to hope for more. It’s a pretty easy thing to consider.

It sounds like you’re trying to have big talks about the past and future when most of this confusion could be cleared up with a little one. He might tell you that he doesn’t know whether you should be seeing others, but that response says a lot, too. It means that after this many years, he still can’t quite commit to your company.

– Meredith

Readers? Is the writer asking the right question? Is this going anywhere?

Advertisement

To comment, please create a screen name in your profile

Love Letters

What’s your love and relationship problem?

Ask Meredith at Love Letters. Yes, it’s anonymous.

Advertisement
About Love Letters
Advertisement