Somehow, my ex got to keep my friends

Hey all, if you’re a column reader, and enjoy any kind of relationship features, please take this survey.

It’s a really great way to procrastinate doing other things.

Q.

Dear Love Letters,

I am a gay woman in my mid-30s who like many queer people, didn’t have her first real relationship until 30. I came out in my mid-20s. We had a loving, healthy four-year relationship, during which she became comfortable enough to come out to her friends and family. She loved me more than anyone ever has, and I think we were the love of each others lives.

After four years, I ended things with her, not because of any betrayal, but because I felt I needed space to grow on my own. It was heartbreaking for her as she felt “dumped,” but I too was broken. It was the worst feeling to have to let someone go when I loved her so much. As much as I hated to do it, my gut told me I wasn’t doing either of us a favor by keeping the relationship going without some time to step back and breathe.

After the breakup, her friends and family cut me off, which I understood. I was the one who ended it, and though there was no wrongdoing, I understood their loyalty to my ex who needed support from “her side.” However, a few of my closest friends became closer to her than they were, even during the time we were dating – inviting her (and later her new partner) to events, trips, and celebrations I also attended. I gently expressed that it made it hard for me to heal, but nothing changed. At first I thought my friends kept in touch with her to soften the blow and to not make her feel as if they weren’t “dumping” her as I did. I was patient and figured it would fade out, but it did not.

Now I feel like I’ve lost friendships I’ve had – for nearly two decades – to someone I introduced into my life. It’s painful, and I’m wondering if I’m wrong to feel betrayed, or if it’s time to reconsider these friendships altogether. Though I understand that they like my ex, I feel like my friendship should take precedence.

I would love to hear your thoughts.

– Anonymous

Advertisement
A.

There are no rules for this. Sure, logic tells me you should have dibs on your friends because you knew them first. But this isn’t a divorce, and your friends aren’t kitchen appliances. Meaning, they’re not a thing that someone “gets” in a settlement. People have free will here. They can do whatever they want.

I don’t think these people are bad friends for loving your ex and wanting her around. They could be nicer about planning some events with a smaller invite list, so you can feel comfortable with everyone in the room. 

You might talk to your friends about that – again. Tell them you don’t expect them to cut anyone out of their lives, but you’d like to spend quality time with them, even if it’s one-on-one. If there’s an excellent listener in the group, take them aside and let them know, with full transparency, how hard this has been. Ask them for advice.

My guess is that your friends might not understand how much you’re struggling. They might need a reminder that you never stopped loving your ex. You needed alone time for important reasons, and you need friends now more than ever.

Do think about what it would take to be able to see your ex without feeling miserable. Maybe more time will heal some wounds. I do hope that one day, you’ll be able to appreciate her role in the group without feeling alienated by it. Or show up on her doorstep and shout, “I love you!” – because you’re ready for more.

Also, yes, it might be nice for you to meet some new friends, not because everyone has failed you, but because it’s good to branch out, and sometimes it’s fun to go to a party where no one reminds you of anyone else. There are apps for making friends and lots of activities out there. I found some excellent like-minded people in my mid-30s. Treat yourself to some new scenery.

– Meredith

Readers? Are these bad friends? Is it fair to ask friends for space from the ex?

What’s on your mind about friendship, breakups, love, exes, dating, love, loss, crushes, marriage, etc.? Submit your letter by using the anonymous form, or email [email protected].

Advertisement

To comment, please create a screen name in your profile

Love Letters

What’s your love and relationship problem?

Ask Meredith at Love Letters. Yes, it’s anonymous.

Advertisement
About Love Letters
Advertisement